Faculty Dismissal Cases before MTI Tribunal – Rights of Employees. - Nouman Muhib Kakakhel

Faculty Dismissal Cases before MTI Tribunal – Rights of Employees.

Faculty Dismissal Cases before MTI Tribunal – Rights of Employees

In Khyber Pakhtunkhwa’s evolving healthcare landscape, Medical Teaching Institutions (MTIs) like Khyber Teaching Hospital and Lady Reading Hospital operate as autonomous bodies under the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Medical Teaching Institutions Act, 2015, transforming public hospitals into corporate entities to enhance efficiency and merit-based governance. Faculty dismissals—often stemming from allegations of misconduct, performance issues, or administrative restructuring—can profoundly affect medical professionals’ careers, given the sector’s emphasis on clinical expertise and patient care. The MTI Appellate Tribunal, established under Section 28 of the Act, provides a specialized forum for aggrieved employees, including clinical and basic science faculty, to challenge such actions, ensuring due process and protection of employment rights. As of September 2025, with ongoing reforms under the KP MTI Reforms Act amendments emphasizing fair hearings, understanding these mechanisms is essential for faculty navigating dismissal disputes in Peshawar’s medical hubs.

This comprehensive guide outlines the Tribunal’s role, employee rights, procedural pathways, and strategies for contesting dismissals, empowering medical educators to safeguard their positions amid institutional accountability demands.

Establishment and Jurisdiction of the MTI Appellate Tribunal

The MTI Appellate Tribunal was constituted to adjudicate service disputes within MTIs, comprising a Chairperson (typically a retired High Court judge) and members with legal or medical expertise, as per Section 28 of the 2015 Act. Headquartered in Peshawar, it holds exclusive jurisdiction over appeals against decisions by MTI Boards of Governors or executive committees, including dismissals, terminations, suspensions, or promotions denials for employees like professors, associate professors, and clinical technicians.

The Tribunal’s mandate aligns with constitutional principles under Article 10A (right to fair trial) and the KP Civil Servants Act, 1973, extending protections to MTI staff who transitioned from provincial service. It does not re-litigate facts but reviews for procedural fairness, legal errors, or arbitrariness. In Peshawar, where MTIs dominate healthcare delivery, the Tribunal has handled cases like those involving nurses and technicians, staying adverse actions pending appeals to prevent irreparable harm.

Grasping the MTI Tribunal jurisdiction scope is foundational for faculty seeking redress.

Grounds for Faculty Dismissal in MTIs

Dismissals in MTIs are governed by Section 16 of the Act, which outlines service rules emphasizing merit, discipline, and performance. Valid grounds include serious misconduct (e.g., ethical breaches under Pakistan Medical and Dental Council standards), inefficiency, absenteeism, or financial irregularities, mirroring Standing Order 15 of the Industrial and Commercial Employment (Standing Orders) Ordinance, 1968. The Board must issue a show-cause notice, allowing 14 days for response, followed by an inquiry if charges persist.

However, arbitrary or discriminatory dismissals—such as those based on union activities or gender—violate fundamental rights under Article 25 of the Constitution. Recent Tribunal interventions, like halting actions against clinical staff in 2023, underscore that dismissals without opportunity to defend contravene natural justice. For faculty, clinical duties and teaching loads factor into performance evaluations, making documentation of contributions crucial.

Identifying grounds for MTI faculty dismissal helps in preempting or contesting actions.

Experience Compassion

We provide compassionate legal support, ensuring clients feel heard, respected, and guided through every step.

Integrity Compassion

Our practice is built on honesty and empathy, delivering ethical and client-focused legal solutions.

Employee Rights in Dismissal Proceedings

MTI employees, deemed public servants under Section 27 of the Act, enjoy robust protections: the right to a fair inquiry, representation by counsel, access to inquiry records, and appeal against adverse findings. Section 16 mandates written reasons for dismissal, with no termination without cause for permanent staff, aligning with broader labor laws prohibiting unfair dismissal. Faculty rights extend to challenging procedural lapses, such as biased inquiry officers or denied cross-examination.

In Peshawar’s MTIs, transitioned civil servants retain pension and seniority benefits under Section 22(8), barring retrospective diminishment. The Tribunal has affirmed equality rights, staying dismissals for clinical technicians pending appeals, emphasizing non-discrimination. Employees can also seek interim relief to maintain salaries during disputes.

Upholding employee rights in MTI dismissals ensures equitable treatment.

Procedure for Appealing Dismissals to the Tribunal

Appeals must be filed within 30 days of the dismissal order under Section 29, extendable for cause like delayed communication. Submit a memorandum to the Tribunal Registrar in Peshawar, detailing grounds (e.g., inquiry flaws), relief sought (reinstatement with back wages), and an index of documents, with a nominal fee (PKR 1,000-5,000).

The Tribunal admits appeals after scrutiny, issuing notices to the MTI Board for responses within 15 days. Hearings, scheduled within 60 days, allow oral arguments, witness examination, and evidence submission, with virtual options for remote faculty. Decisions aim for disposal within 90-120 days, reasoned and enforceable as civil decrees.

For Peshawar-based cases, local inquiries into hospital records expedite proceedings.

Mastering the MTI appeal procedure streamlines challenges.

Powers and Remedies of the Tribunal

Under Section 30, the Tribunal wields civil court powers, summoning records, enforcing attendance, and granting interim stays on dismissals to prevent service breaks. Remedies include quashing orders, directing reinstatement with continuity of service, or modifying penalties (e.g., demotion to warning). It can award costs for mala fide actions and refer matters for fresh inquiries.

In faculty cases, the Tribunal has reinstated dismissed professors where evidence showed vindictive motives, awarding arrears. Non-compliance invites contempt proceedings, ensuring enforceability.

Harnessing Tribunal remedial powers restores professional standing.

Documentation and Evidence Essentials

Appeals require certified copies of the dismissal order, show-cause notice, inquiry report, and response submissions. Faculty should include performance appraisals, PMDC registrations, teaching logs, and affidavits from colleagues. Medical evidence counters health-related allegations.

Digital filings via the KP Judiciary portal are preferred, with notarized hard copies. Peshawar appellants leverage MTI archives for contextual proof.

A MTI dismissal evidence guide fortifies submissions.

Timelines, Costs, and Further Recourse

Appeals file within 30 days, resolving in 3-6 months; High Court writs under Article 199 add 6-12 months for legal errors. Fees are minimal, but legal costs range PKR 50,000-200,000. Supreme Court appeals under Article 185 follow for substantial issues.

Track via Tribunal notices; Peshawar High Court circuit benches aid access.

The MTI case timelines overview supports planning.

Common Challenges and Mitigation Strategies

Hurdles include time-barred appeals or weak inquiry challenges, risking dismissals. In Peshawar, administrative delays prolong uncertainties.

Strategies: Document interactions meticulously, cite precedents like Tribunal stays on technician dismissals, and seek early stays. Pre-appeal negotiations resolve amicably.

Overcoming dismissal challenge pitfalls bolsters success.

Value of Expert Legal Assistance in Peshawar

MTI disputes blend service laws and medical ethics, demanding specialized advocacy. Nouman Muhib Kakakhel – Lawyer & Legal Consultant excels in Peshawar, drafting appeals and representing before the Tribunal, ensuring alignment with 2015 Act reforms.

Engaging expert employment defense counsel maximizes rights protection.

Conclusion: Upholding Faculty Rights in MTIs

The MTI Appellate Tribunal safeguards employee rights in faculty dismissal cases, promoting fairness in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa’s medical institutions. By leveraging appeals and due process, dismissed professionals can reclaim careers, contributing to healthcare excellence.

Stay updated via MTI Board notifications and consult experts like Nouman Muhib Kakakhel – Lawyer & Legal Consultant for tailored support. Informed action preserves not just jobs, but institutional integrity.